Are There VA Disability Claims That Cannot Be Proven?

Home / Blog / Are There VA Disability Claims That Cannot Be Proven?

Filing a VA (US Department of Veterans Affairs) disability claim can feel complicated and frustrating. Many veterans ask a tough question: “Are there VA disability claims that cannot be proven?”

The short answer is that most claims can be proven, but only with the right evidence and preparation. If a claim fails, it usually means the VA decided one or more of the requirements weren’t met.

This article explains which claims are most difficult, why they fail, and how you can build a case for your claim to succeed.

What the VA Looks For in Every Disability Claim

To succeed with a VA disability claim, you must show that you meet the VA’s eligibility rules and the legal requirements for service connection. Together, these form the foundation of every claim.

The VA looks for five key elements:

Eligible service: You must have served on active duty, active duty for training, or inactive duty training.
Discharge status: Most veterans need a discharge that is not dishonorable.
Current disability: A medical diagnosis showing you have the condition today.
In-service event or illness: Proof of something that happened during your service, such as an injury, illness, or exposure.
Nexus (connection to service): A link between your current disability and your in-service event. This usually requires medical evidence.

The VA also considers severity, or how much your condition impacts daily life, work, and relationships. This determines your rating percentage. Ratings range from 0% to 100%, reflect how much a disability limits your ability to function. A higher percentage means more severe impairment and greater monthly compensation.

Meeting these requirements is essential for a successful claim.

Common Reasons VA Denies Claims

Even when a veteran has a valid condition, the VA often denies claims because one or more of the required elements are missing or incomplete. These are some of the most common reasons:

No medical records or diagnosis: Without a clear, current diagnosis, the VA may say there’s no disability to compensate.
No nexus opinion: If no medical professional connects your condition to your service, the VA often denies the link.
Missing or vague service records: When there’s no proof of an in-service event, or the documentation is weak, the VA may reject the claim.
Symptoms not clearly documented: Conditions that don’t show up on lab tests, like chronic pain or mental health struggles, can be dismissed if evidence isn’t detailed.
Discharge status issues: Veterans with a dishonorable or other-than-honorable discharge may not meet VA’s eligibility requirements.

These denials don’t always mean the claim is unprovable, only that the VA didn’t see enough evidence to meet its standards. With stronger documentation, nexus letters, or supporting evidence, many of these cases can be turned around.

Claims That Are Harder to Prove

There are no VA disability claims that are completely impossible, but some are harder than others. Common examples include:

Invisible Injuries: Conditions such as fibromyalgia or chronic pain. These are difficult because they don’t always show up on lab tests or imaging.
Mental Health Claims: A VA claim for PTSD or depression can be challenging without clear service records or early treatment. Many veterans didn’t report symptoms while serving, making it harder to connect the dots later.
Secondary Service Connection: Proving that one condition caused another, like sleep apnea caused by PTSD. These claims require strong medical opinions.
Exposure-related Claims: Burn pits, Agent Orange (outside presumptive conditions), radiation, or contaminated water exposure cases often lack records of direct exposure.
Claims Without Service Records: Sometimes, records are missing or destroyed. Veterans then need to rely on private medical files, lay statements (supporting statements). from former squad members or superiors, or other supporting evidence.

These are tough, but with the right documentation and strategy, they can often be won.

Can Some VA Claims Truly Not Be Proven?

There isn’t a list of conditions the VA says can never be proven. Instead, claims fail when:

A diagnosis is missing.
No in-service event is established.
No nexus opinion is provided.
Symptoms aren’t shown to affect daily life.

No claim is impossible. However, if the evidence is weak, the VA may deny it.

How to Strengthen Your Claim: Practical Tips

Claim Practical Tips

Even the hardest claims can often be proven with the right strategy. Here are practical steps that can make a difference:

Get a diagnosis: Even if you weren’t diagnosed in service, you need one now.
Request all medical records: Both VA and private records help fill gaps. Keeping a complete file prevents delays.
Use alternate records: Submit lay statements from family, friends, or fellow service members who see how your condition affects you
Keep a symptom journal: Document when symptoms occur, how long they last, and how they affect your work or daily life.
Obtain a nexus letter: A doctor’s statement linking your condition to service is often the missing piece that wins a claim.
Check presumptive conditions: If your disability is on the VA presumptive service connection list, you may not need to prove the in-service event.
File secondary claims when needed: If one disability caused another, connect them with medical evidence.
Never miss your C&P (Compensation and Pension) exam: Skipping it can result in denial. Be honest and thorough about your symptoms.
Work with representation: Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) or accredited attorneys like Unruh Law, P.C. can guide you and strengthen your case.

By taking these steps, you put yourself in the best position to prove your claim and avoid unnecessary denials or delays.

What to Do If the VA Denies Your Claim

Even if your claim is denied, you can appeal. The appeal process may include:

Higher-Level Review: A senior reviewer re-examines the evidence.
Supplemental Claim: You add new and relevant evidence.
Board Appeal: You take your case to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals.

Many “unprovable” claims in the past have succeeded on appeal once stronger evidence is submitted.

Why It Matters

Your VA disability claim affects much more than monthly compensation. A correct rating impacts:

Access to VA healthcare services
Eligibility for vocational or housing programs
State veteran benefits
Stability for your family

That’s why proving your claim matters. Having the right strategy can mean the difference between denial and long-term support.

Why Choose Unruh Law, P.C.?

At Unruh Law, P.C., we know how frustrating it feels when the VA denies your claim or says your case “cannot be proven.” Our team helps veterans across the U.S. build strong claims, appeal bad decisions, and fight for the benefits they’ve earned.

Here’s what we offer:

Nationwide representation: We work with veterans in every state and around the world.
Clear guidance: We explain each step so you know what to expect.
Evidence building: We help gather the records, nexus letters, and lay statements you need.
No upfront fees: We work with a contingency fee.

Take the Next Step

If you’ve been told your VA disability claim cannot be proven, don’t give up. With the right evidence and representation, many of these claims are not only possible, but they’re winnable.

Contact Unruh Law, P.C. today for a free case review. We’ll help you understand your options, strengthen your case, and pursue the benefits you earned through your service.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What conditions are most commonly considered hard to prove?
Invisible conditions such as fibromyalgia, chronic pain, and certain mental health disorders are often challenging. Exposure-related illnesses, like burn pit claims, can also be tough due to a lack of direct records.

2. Can I still file a VA disability claim years after leaving service?
Yes. There is no strict deadline to file. Many veterans apply decades later. The key is providing current medical evidence and showing how the condition connects to your service.

3. Does the VA treat mental health claims differently from physical ones?
Not in terms of rating structure, but proving service connection for mental health can be harder since symptoms are often less documented during service. This makes supporting statements and medical opinions critical.

4. How do lay statements help in a difficult claim?
Lay statements (supporting statements) from family, friends, or fellow service members describe what they see day to day. They can bridge gaps when medical or service records are missing.

5. Can secondary conditions also be hard to prove?
Yes. For example, proving that sleep apnea was caused by PTSD requires medical evidence showing a direct link. Secondary claims often need strong nexus opinions.

Are There VA Disability Claims That Cannot Be Proven?

Fill Out This Form To Get A Free Case Review

We’ll Fight For You