What is The Most Challenging VA Disability Claim?

Home / Blog / What is The Most Challenging VA Disability Claim?

Not all VA (US Department of Veterans Affairs) disability claims are created equal. Some are straightforward, which are backed by clear medical records and easy-to-trace service connections. Others are much more complicated, requiring years of documentation, multiple appeals, and specialized evidence. Veterans often ask, “What is the most challenging VA disability claim to get approved?”

The answer isn’t always simple. Certain conditions are consistently more challenging because they rely heavily on subjective symptoms, lack direct medical testing, or involve events that weren’t documented during service. This article looks at why some claims are harder than others, which conditions are most commonly considered difficult, and what steps can help improve the chances of success.

Why Some VA Claims Are Harder Than Others?

A VA disability claim becomes difficult when certain legal or evidence hurdles are involved. Some of the major challenges include:

Invisible or subjectively reported conditions: Conditions like PTSD, depression, anxiety, or chronic pain often don’t come with lab tests or X-rays. The symptoms are there, but proving them requires strong documentation, supporting statements, and medical opinions.
Lack of service connection: Veterans must show the condition began during service or was worsened by it. If records are missing or if the in-service event wasn’t documented, it will be difficult to approve their disability claims
Delayed treatment or absence of treatment during service: If you did not seek or record treatment while in service, or if symptoms appeared long after leaving service, VA often looks for supporting proof to fill that gap.
Need for special diagnostic tests or studies: For example, sleep apnea often requires a sleep study. If the study wasn’t done during service, you may need extra medical evidence.
Severity and how it affects work/life: Even when a service connection is established, VA wants to know how bad it is. Does it impact your ability to maintain employment, relationships, or daily tasks? If that impact isn’t well documented, the amount you receive from your benefit will be lower.

Which VA Claims Are Difficult to Get Approved?

Based on what veterans experience, certain types of claims come up again and again as difficult to get approved:

PTSD and other mental health conditions: These are difficult because symptoms are subjective, stressor events may not be documented, and nexus opinions are often required.
Sleep apnea: Approval usually depends on a sleep study, and if it wasn’t done in service, proving service connection is tough.
Invisible injuries or exposure-related illnesses: Burn pit exposure, chemical exposure, and chronic fatigue syndrome can be very challenging without service records or objective tests.
Secondary conditions: Proving that one service-connected condition caused another requires strong medical evidence.

Why PTSD and Mental Health Claims Are Especially Challenging?

PTSD and Mental Health Claims

Many veterans and attorneys consider PTSD among the most challenging VA claims to win. The reasons include:

Lack of in-service documentation: Many service members didn’t report mental health issues at the time.
Difficulty proving the stressor event: Without written records, it can be challenging to confirm the event happened.
Subjective symptoms: Flashbacks, nightmares, and depression don’t show up on medical scans, which makes proof harder.
Need for expert opinions: Psychologists or psychiatrists often must write a nexus letter to tie the condition to military service.

Factors That Make Any VA Claim Harder

While some conditions are known to be difficult, any VA disability claim can become hard to win if certain factors are present. These include:

Missing or destroyed service records: If your medical or service records are incomplete, proving a connection becomes much more challenging.
Delayed filing: Veterans who wait years or decades to file often face questions about whether the condition really began in service.
Conflicting medical evidence: If different doctors give different opinions, the VA may deny the claim until stronger evidence is provided.
Lack of consistent treatment: Gaps in medical history can raise doubts about the severity or continuity of symptoms.
Weak nexus evidence: Without a clear medical opinion linking your disability to service, even obvious conditions can be denied.
These factors don’t mean a claim is unwinnable. But they do mean veterans will need stronger documentation, medical support, or appeals to succeed.

Steps to Make a Difficult Claim Stronger

If you are dealing with one of the harder claims, there are practical steps you can take to improve your chances:

Document your symptoms: Keep a journal of when symptoms occur, how severe they are, and how they affect daily life.
Seek medical opinions: Ask your doctor for a nexus letter explaining how your condition is connected to your service.
Collect service records: Even if your service treatment records are missing, deployment orders or unit logs may help.
Use lay statements: Family, friends, or fellow service members who see how your condition affects you can write letters to support your case.
Work with experienced support: Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) or accredited attorneys can help build a stronger claim.
Appeal if denied: Many of these claims are initially denied but later approved on appeal with more evidence.

Why Hard VA Claims Matter for Veterans?

Hard claims aren’t just an annoyance; they impact real lives. These cases often:

Take longer to process
They are denied more often at first
Leave veterans without fair compensation
Causes financial strain and stress

At the same time, these cases are often the most important ones. A successful claim can mean higher monthly compensation, better healthcare access, and more support for you and your family.

Why Choose Unruh Law, P.C.?

At Unruh Law, P.C., we help veterans whose claims seem like they might be among the most challenging. We guide you through gathering evidence, building nexus opinions, and presenting your case so that even difficult claims get a shot at approval.

If you believe your claim is facing major challenges or if you’ve been denied because of missing or vague evidence, just reach out. We can help you see what’s missing, repair weak points, and pursue the benefits you deserve.

Take the Next Step

Filing a VA disability claim is rarely simple, and some cases are much harder than others. If you’re struggling with PTSD, sleep apnea, exposure-related illnesses, or another difficult claim, don’t assume it’s impossible. With the right evidence and support, even the toughest cases can succeed.

Reach out today for a free consultation and learn how you can build a stronger claim, avoid common pitfalls, and pursue the benefits you earned through your service.

FAQs

1. What makes a VA disability claim take longer than usual?
Delays happen when the VA requests extra evidence, when medical records are missing, or when exams need to be rescheduled. Difficult claims often involve more back-and-forth.

2. Can lifestyle factors affect whether my claim is approved?
Yes. For example, if sleep apnea is linked to obesity instead of service, the VA may deny the claim. The VA looks closely at other causes when deciding service connection.

3. Can invisible injuries be proven in a VA claim?
Yes, but they’re harder. Conditions like fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue don’t always show up on medical tests. Consistent treatment records, symptom journals, and lay statements are critical.

4. What role do lay statements play?
Lay statements (supporting statements) from family, friends, or fellow service members can describe how your condition impacts daily life. They help fill gaps when service records or medical documentation are incomplete.

5. How long does it take for the VA to decide a difficult claim?
Harder claims often take longer, sometimes many months or even years. Missing records, appeals, or the need for extra evidence can extend the timeline.

6. Can secondary conditions also be hard to prove?
Yes. Proving that one service-connected condition caused another, like migraines linked to TBI(Traumatic Brain Injury), requires strong medical evidence. Secondary claims are often denied without a solid nexus opinion.

7. What if my service records were lost or destroyed?
You can still file. Veterans can use alternate evidence, such as deployment orders, medical records after service, or lay statements, to help fill the gap.

8. Do all hard claims get denied the first time?
Not always, but many do. The VA often denies tough claims initially. Appeals with new evidence or better documentation have a much higher chance of success.

9. Should I get help with a difficult VA claim?
Yes. Many veterans succeed after working with accredited attorneys or VSOs who understand how to build strong claims and appeals. Guidance can make the process less overwhelming.

What is The Most Challenging VA Disability Claim?

Fill Out This Form To Get A Free Case Review

We’ll Fight For You